Peoria, IL Pizza Delivery - Nick-N-Willy's Pizza Peoria

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Your Favorites Delivered to You!

Name: Nick-N-Willy's Pizza Peoria
Address: 4700 N University St #90, Peoria, IL, 61614, United States
Telephone: (309) 691-2345
Price range: $

Order Online Call Us

Browse Our Favorites

Aegean Pizza

Olive oil glaze, Mozzarella cheese, spinach, fresh garlic, marinated sun-dried tomatoes, Feta, and oregano.

Aegean Pizza

Olive oil glaze, Mozzarella cheese, spinach, fresh garlic, marinated sun-dried tomatoes, Feta, and oregano.

Order Now

Big Kahuna Pizza

Fresh tomato sauce, Mozzarella cheese, Canadian bacon, pineapple and mandarin oranges topped with Cheddar and...

Big Kahuna Pizza

Fresh tomato sauce, Mozzarella cheese, Canadian bacon, pineapple and mandarin oranges topped with Cheddar and...

Order Now

Earthborn Pizza

Fresh tomato sauce, Mozzarella, Provolone and Cheddar cheeses with green and red peppers, marinated artichoke...

Earthborn Pizza

Fresh tomato sauce, Mozzarella, Provolone and Cheddar cheeses with green and red peppers, marinated artichoke...

Order Now

Nick-N-Willy's Classic Pizza

Fresh tomato sauce, Mozzarella, Cheddar and Provolone cheeses, mushrooms, black olives, pepperoni and your choice...

Nick-N-Willy's Classic Pizza

Fresh tomato sauce, Mozzarella, Cheddar and Provolone cheeses, mushrooms, black olives, pepperoni and your choice...

Order Now

Voted Best Pizza in Peoria, IL

Peoria’s Award-Winning Pizza: Nick-N-Willy’s Looking for the best pizza in Peoria? Look no further than Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza, voted Peoria’s best pizza! We use only the freshest ingredients to create our delicious signature pizzas, ultimate pizzas, and create-your-own pizzas. We also offer a variety of sandwiches, wraps, salads, and sides. Stop by today and experience the Nick-N-Willy’s difference – we guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

Learn More About Us

What our Customers Are Saying:

Jason Stein
11/04/2025

I got the meat eaters pizza. Absolutely recommend. Reasonable prices. Reasonable wait time. Clean. Reasonably quiet. Just simple good food.

D. M.
03/31/2025

Do I think this is world class pizza? No. But do I think it’s delicious? Yes. Let’s start with this place being in Peoria for ages, and I am late to the game in trying it but I was very impressed. The flavor of the pizza is great, I ordered the chicken and bacon, on a thin crust and it was very good. I also ordered the cheese bread, and that’s truly what will have me come back again The cheese was so soft and had the best cheese pull with a slight garlicky flavor and crispy crunchy outside. I would quite literally order that bread and pile toppings on it and have a great night. Besides that- the employees are so nice. Bringing us extra plates, dipping sauce , and being so welcoming. That’s what makes this place a 5 star. The pizza is great but the people are even better. Will be going here for all of my pizza and cheese bread cravings.

Welcome You
03/09/2025

My most recent experience would have been about my third time ordering pizza from here and I have always received a great product each time. I arrived to pickup my order this time and needed to wait a few minutes for them to finish. When I was given my pizza I was also given an apology along with a second pizza for free. It was explained that the first pizza they made accidently had a different type of sausage than what I had ordered and that it was promptly remade. Most would have ignored the issue and hoped I didn't catch it. Thank you for the honesty and the delicious food. I highly recommend Nick-N-Willy's Pizza.

Jeff Longfellow
10/08/2024

We tried a half Outlbacker/half 5 Cheese with Pepperoni and it was incredible! We shall return!

Shaun Elias (Tire Tracks)
09/28/2024

This is a great place tucked away in the corner of the plaza. They offer dining or take 'n bake option. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting. I like the stuffed garlic cheesey bread the most!

Ervie Beckner
09/25/2024

My first experience dining there! It was amazing service and one of the best pizzas that I have ever had. Very clean and friendly service! Will definitely be back!

Chef King Curry
08/29/2024

I had a Great experience here. I had the Outback pizza and I added to chicken on it. It was delicious, nice and crispy. 9/10. 2nd I had the stuffed cheese bread. Which was tasty super cheesy and the bread was fresh. 8.5/10. Last but not least the chicken wrap. It was great very fresh. 7.5/10. Food Game 9/10. Price Game 7.5/10 overall Nick N Willy's 9/10

Kiel Eudaley
06/30/2024

Absolutely amazing!! They work so so hard to provide and prepare fresh dough.. fresh fresh dough..Everything from the green and red peppers to mushrooms...to spinach to toman are cut by hand.... sauces made by hand..salads made by hand......garlic bread out of this world...

Mark Henry
06/12/2024

Every pizza I have gotten here has been worthy of getting again. The calmness inside is always inviting and the staff is always super friendly! Absolutely worth coming to try!!

Tom
05/18/2024

Great food. Great prices. Staff is always helpful and friendly.

Blake Richmond
01/04/2024

I've had this pizza for years. Last one I had with the white garlic was pretty good.

Christopher Estrada
08/21/2023

Everyone here is always so polite, pizza is delicious, AND the take-n-bake option is a total life saver when I forget to defrost the chicken

Willie Howe
06/04/2023

Nick and Willy's never disappoints! Fast, friendly service and great food! Try the Nick and Willy classic personal pizza!

Alexander Molins
03/19/2023

Very friendly owner. I had the personal margaritas pizza with Peppers. It was excellent! I'd say one of the best pizzas in Peoria! Kid-friendliness: A very wholesome environment! Sports memorabilia on the walls. And very clean and neat. Parking: Close, ample parking.

Jon Kucharz
02/19/2023

Been going here for years. It's one of Peoria's hidden gems.

Jen Benningfield
02/19/2023

My favorite take and bake pizza by far. Everyone is always so friendly to order from and pizza is always made correctly. Everyone who is new to it also is hooked. My favorite is the outback pictured below and also the Magellan. We like the garlic cream sauce for a 2 topping pizza with Canadian bacon and ground beef. Usually coupons can be found and they do have daily specials. Two family size pizzas can easily feed 8 people.

syed hussain
10/19/2022

Aegean!!!

Patricia Jones
08/19/2022

First time here but not the last. Greeted when we came in door. He was helpful when trying to decide which pizza we wanted. Thank you for a great experience.

Heckathorn
05/19/2022

One of the best small resturants in & around Peoria. A hidden gem of the metro center.

Zak J
05/19/2022

My dad had his birthday party here. I had never been before, and didn't know what to expect. After several hours of thought, I have concluded this is the best pizza in the area. Perfectly crisp cheese and crust, generous portions of toppings, and an actual fresh taste really puts this place above the others. The food was so good that I bought a bake at home giant cookie that was just as impressive. Everyone was polite and attentive, but not overbearing. Good prices too.

Emilee Cox
05/19/2022

It's always amazing when we come here. Food is always hot and fresh and delicious!

Chase Brower
05/19/2022

Awesome take n bake. Good ingredients, flavors and people. Only place we go for take n bake after moving here.

Ed Black
05/19/2022

Nice selection of menu items at a decent value. Pizza was great!

Ed Hausser
05/19/2022

BBQ Chicken Pizza is fantastic!

Michelle Gannon
05/19/2022

So good. I took my pizza home and baked it. So very delicious.

Kathy Puckett
05/19/2021

Great take-home soecialty pizza!

Renea Cox
05/19/2021

Great pizza. Friendly service workers.

Rob Lambie
05/19/2021

Wednesday is our company pizza day here. Good food and good servicr

Brad Kahler
05/19/2021

Our family's favorite pizza in Peoria. Great gluten free crust options

Aaron Taraboletti
05/19/2020

One of my favorite places for lunch. The jalapeno burn pizza is my go to.

Jacob Bankston
05/19/2020

You almost don't notice this place, tucked back into the corner at the Metro Center, near Naturally Yours. I've mentioned it to friends who've lived in Peoria all their lives and never knew about it. I've been curious about trying it for over a year and finally did! WOW! The pizza is so awesome, and their daily specials are the best (large pizza for the price of a medium)! I've been there twice this week, and wish I had discovered this place a long time ago! It will be my go to place for takeout pizza now. :-)

Ryan Elder
05/19/2020

Always good pizza

Sonya Rose
05/19/2020

Always look forward to the 3rd Thursday of the month for some awesome pizza! They never disappoint. 👍🍕🍕

greg mathews
06/14/2019

First time for me, the stuffed cheesy bread stick was awesome. The pizza had a nice thin crust, flavorful sauce a nice amount of ingredients. Service was very good, the two young ladies were very nice and attentive to your needs. If you haven't tried it you should.

Peoria’s Flavor-Packed Favorite: Aegean Pizza

Ready to take your taste buds on a Mediterranean escape? Meet the Aegean Pizza—a vibrant, flavor-packed journey to sun-soaked shores, only at Nick-N-Willy’s!

We begin with our handcrafted, oven-ready crust and brush it with a delicate olive oil glaze, creating a silky, aromatic foundation. A generous layer of melty mozzarella cheese follows, stretching and bubbling into every nook to form the perfect cheesy base.

Next, we pile on fresh spinach and fragrant, freshly minced garlic, adding a bright, garden-fresh punch in every bite. Marinated sun-dried tomatoes bring a sweet-tangy depth, perfectly balanced with crumbles of creamy feta cheese. Finally, we sprinkle a touch of oregano for that signature Mediterranean aroma that ties every flavor together.

The Aegean Pizza is a sun-drenched, savory feast—fresh, tangy, cheesy, and utterly irresistible. Savor the Mediterranean. Taste the adventure. Only at Nick-N-Willy’s!

Order Now

Locally Owned and Operated

About Us

4700 N University St #90
Peoria, IL 61614

(309) 691-2345

Order Now

Store Hours

Monday
- 11:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Tuesday
- 11:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Wednesday
- 11:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Thursday
- 11:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Friday
- 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Saturday
- 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Sunday
- 12:00 PM - 07:00 PM

Daily Pizza Specials and Daily Combos

Daily Combos

Signature Personal and Fountain Drink — $10.50
One Topping Personal and Fountain Drink — $9.75
Sandwich, Fountain Drink, and Chips — $11.25
Signature Slice and Fountain Drink — $9.25
One Topping Slice and Fountain Drink — $7.50
Entrée Salad and Fountain Drink — $6.50
Wrap, Fountain Drink, and Chips — $11.25

Specials

Monday: Large 5 Cheese — $18
Tuesday: Large Margherita — $18
Wednesday: 2 Large Signature — $38
Thursday: Large Wombacher — $18
Friday/Saturday: Large Signature + 2 Side Salads + Garlic Bread — $27
Sunday: Large Mediterranean — $18

Peoria, IL Pizza Delivery

Where We Deliver

61614
61616
61615
61603
61611
61606
61625
61613
61638
61637
61601
61612
61653
61629
61656
61643
61650

61651
61604
61602
61552
61635
61605
61528
61525
61634
61636
61652
61639
61610
61571
61607
61562
61630

61654
61655
61641
61548
61523
61536
61526
61535
61547
61558
61555
61550
61559
61517
61545
61554
61633